I don’t mean to brag—ok, maybe I do—but when I make changes to recipes, I am often satisfied with the results. Often I get to simplify a recipe, or explore a different technique. But other times, my adjustments produce a complete flop. And even when they don’t flop, sometimes I realize I should have just followed the recipe. Such was the case with this apple and fennel salad.
It all comes down to the shallot. The recipe called for using half a shallot in the vinaigrette for the salad. But I thought, what am I going to do with a left over half of a shallot? (It occurs to me now, of course, that I could do lots of things) So when Thomas asked if he should cut up a half or whole shallot, I replied, “The whole shallot and nothing but the whole shallot, so help you god.” Oh, I thought I was so funny. Cut to us eating the salad, our eyes watering from an excess of onion, which a shallot is a tiny version of.
I might have called this a loss due to my own poor judgment. But everything else about this salad intrigued me and tasted delicious. Despite the excess of shallots, the vinaigrette was especially good. You combine a bit of chopped apple, those shallots, apple cider vinegar, and powdered mustard, let the mixture sit for 10 minutes, and stir in some olive oil. While it sits, the mixture macerates (meaning it softens in the liquid). This is not your typical bottled dressing. The vinegar provides a sharp zing of crisp apple, mellowed by olive oil. In other words, it’s lively and perfect for dressing up a ho-hum pile of greens.
The combination of granny smith apple and fennel bulb is another genius move. Both ingredients have their own crispness and crunch, but different yet complimentary flavors. Fennel smells like licorice (not Twizzlers, but the real stuff, the black licorice you either scorn or love) or more accurately, anise. It crunches similar to celery, but without the stringiness. As for a crunchy granny smith apple, it is tart with just a hint of sweetness, and pairs well with the vinaigrette, the fennel, the greens, everything. I decided to use a whole apple instead of half, as the recipe suggested, and it was an adjustment I did not regret.
My experience with this salad doesn’t mean I’ll never mess with another recipe again—because what fun would that be? But for this one, please use only half a shallot in the vinaigrette (unless you really like onions). There are plenty of things you can do with a leftover half a shallot.
Apple and Fennel Salad
Adapted from Bon Appetit
1 granny smith apple
½ small shallot, chopped finely
2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
¾ teaspoon powdered yellow mustard
3 tablespoons olive oil
½ fennel bulb, diced
4 cups mixed greens, spinach, or lettuce
- Cut a small slice from the apple. Finely chop the slice (you should have roughly a tablespoon of chopped apple). Place diced apple in a small bowl. Add chopped shallot. Whisk in cider vinegar and powdered yellow mustard. Let mixture sit for 10 minutes (this allows it to macerate—in other words, soften). Whisk in olive oil.
- Dice the remaining apple. In a large bowl, combine the apple, fennel, and greens. Pour the vinaigrette over the salad in 2-3 batches, tossing well after each addition so the salad is well coated.
Variations: You could add a variety of ingredients to this salad, including chicken, tofu, pork, tempeh, and white fish. Dried fruit, particularly cranberries or dried apples (if you just can’t get enough apple) would be great.