Like many famous pairings—fries and ketchup, apple pie and ice cream, and so on—grilled cheese and tomato soup can’t seem to get away from each other. And why not? It’s a superb combination: the melted cheese, the soup bursting with tomato flavor. But if you read this post’s title you already know I have other things on my mind. I have nothing against tried and true matches, including grilled cheese and tomato soup. This post doesn’t derive from necessity or rebellion, but from a craving for a grilled cheese sandwich on the night I’d already planned to make potato soup.
Potato soup isn’t complicated; it’s a simple meal, one that warms you up slowly, in a comforting way, rather than all at once with a kick of spice (ahem, chili). It’s pared-down chowder, without clams or heavy cream to weigh it down (but if you’d prefer that, here’s an excellent recipe). The recipe suggested toppings—bacon bits, green onions, and cheddar—but I knew such a basic soup still needed a strong counterpart that would add an assertive side to the meal without scaring the soup away. Crackers or pita triangles wouldn’t cut it. I recalled from the night before that we had a large block of cheddar in the fridge, and I decided I couldn’t have so much cheddar at my disposal and not make grilled cheese.
The soup was a snap: the potatoes cook in the microwave; then you chop the potatoes, sauté a little onion, and add milk, broth, and flour; simmer; and stir in the potatoes. While the soup is simmering away, you can cook the bacon and slice the green onions (I left out the extra grated cheddar from the sandwiches for the soup, but with grilled cheese sandwiches on the side it’s not really necessary. Yes, even I have my limits). Making the grilled cheese is quick, too: I used two vital tips from Ruth Reichl’s “How to Make a Better Grilled Cheese” on Gilt Taste: butter both sides of the bread, and grate the cheese, rather than slicing it, for faster, more even melting. In my impatience—I mean, efficiency—I put the sandwiches in an oven-proof skillet and broiled one side, then flipped the sandwiches and broiled the other. It’s a risky method, because broiling happens quickly, but watch it carefully and it shouldn’t be a problem.
While it contains no cream, the soup isn’t watery; the milk, with help from a little flour, thickens it just enough. Sure, it’s not as rich, but that’s not a bad thing. You’re left to enjoy the mingling of milk and broth, which creates a savory, smooth background, infused with the subtle heat of the onions which, if cooked only a little at the beginning, preserve just enough of their crunch. The potatoes crumble with the touch of a spoon, and absorb the flavors of the broth and onions. I’m pretty sure I don’t have to tell you how good grilled cheese sandwiches are.
Famous food duos get that way for a reason, and I’m not suggesting grilled cheese be forever parted from tomato soup. Convention is comforting, especially in hard times and cold winter nights. But convention, even when it comes to grilled cheese and tomato soup, should never be the last word.
Potato Soup
Adapted from Cooking Light
Notes: If you make these baked potatoes and have leftover potatoes, you can use them to make this soup. The toppings are also the same, which makes planning meals and grocery shopping that much easier.
This makes enough for about four people to have for dinner. If you want leftovers, double it.
The soup tastes even better the next day, after it’s set overnight in the fridge and had even more time to thicken.
4 medium russet potatoes, scrubbed
2 teaspoons olive oil
½ cup diced white onion
1 ¼ cups chicken or vegetable broth
3 tablespoons all purpose flour
2 cups 1 percent milk
¼ cup sour cream
6 slices turkey bacon or regular bacon
Grated cheddar, for garnish
Diced green onions, for garnish
Salt and pepper to taste
- Poke holes in potatoes with a fork. Place on a microwave-safe plate and cook on high for 15 minutes or until tender. Cut in half and allow to cool. Cut potatoes into bite-size pieces. Set aside.
- While potatoes are microwaving, heat oil in a saucepan over medium heat. Add onion and sauté for 3 minutes. Add broth. In a separate bowl, combine ½ cup milk with flour. Add to pan along with remaining milk. Bring to a low simmer, stirring often. You might be tempted to turn up the heat, but keep it at medium to avoid scalding the milk. Let simmer for 1 minute, then remove soup from heat. Add sour cream and salt and pepper to taste.
- Cook the bacon in the microwave or in a pan, until crisp. Break into small pieces.
- Add potatoes to soup, stirring to combine. Serve soup with bacon bits, cheddar, and green onions.
Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Sliced bread
Melted butter (how much depends on how many sandwiches you want to make. Remember, a little goes a long way)
Grated cheese (orange cheddar, white cheddar, or colby are good options)
- Set the oven to broil. Spread both sides of each bread slice with a bit of melted butter. Place half of the slices on a cookie sheet or in an oven-proof skillet. Top each bread slice with grated cheese. Place the remaining bread slices on top.
- When the broiler is ready, broil the sandwiches. When the side facing up is lightly browned, flip the sandwiches; they are done when both sides are lightly browned. I have found that about 45 seconds per side works best, but your broiler might be different. Monitor carefully and always err on the side of too little time.